
Who pays for free delivery?

When free delivery online turns out to be expensive: who pays for what you save
Delivery at no extra cost can be bait for customers and ruin for small retailers
When Ana Magallón sold her first order to Hawaii, she got a little excited. “I thought: how exotic, one of our pieces is going to travel from Avilés to a paradise island,” she recalls. Then she started doing the maths and got a little less excited. The piece in question, a little ceramic mermaid, cost 10 euros. Delivery came to 15. “We absorbed some of the cost so it wouldn’t seem so expensive,” explains the craftswoman behind the online shop Barruntando. It is common practice in the world of ecommerce. The seller covers part or all of the delivery costs so as not to put the customer off. Profit margins shrink, but sales rise. If you are a large company, this can work; if you are a small craftswoman like Magallón, it can end up suffocating you. Free delivery does not exist, and yet it is everywhere. Amazon guarantees it for 36 euros a year. Aliexpress offers it across the board. Etsy recommends it to its sellers as a marketing strategy. Every ecommerce business has copied a tactic based on two principles: do it fast and do it free. When you press the buy button, a race against the clock begins, a relay race that reaches the finish line when the courier knocks at your door. At some point along that chain, the delivery costs you have not paid are charged to someone. Somebody picks up the bill: delivery drivers living in precarious conditions, Correos, which provides a loss-making service subsidised by the State, or the seller, who cuts their profit margin to compete in the fierce online world.
It has not always been like this. When Magallón founded her shop with classmates from a ceramics course, things were different. “I had some previous experience online, so I took the plunge and we started on Etsy,” the entrepreneur explains. “Within a week we had already sold something.” It was 2014, and customers thought very differently from how they do today. “They accepted delivery costs without any problem,” Magallón explains. “They understood there was work behind it and that it had to be paid for.” But when the big companies saw there was business potential online, they began attracting customers with aggressive offers such as free delivery. Small shops had to copy them to keep selling. And they began absorbing costs across the board. Barruntando, for example, has ended up absorbing delivery costs within Spain and sharing them with the customer when orders go abroad. Ecommerce in Spain is worth around 12,000 million euros per quarter. It has become the goose that lays the golden eggs, but the conditions in which they are hatched are increasingly precarious. “For years free delivery has been promoted because it was the way to compete in a growing market and because, in many cases, the numbers allowed it,” explains technology consultant José Carlos Cortizo. It is a process that is still going on, and at cruising speed: this market is growing at close to 30% year on year in Spain. There is room to keep winning over new customers, and the easiest way to do that is by eliminating costs. Brands keep adjusting prices, and some drop out of this crazy competition along the way. ”In this whirlwind, many retailers are forced to sell at prices that simply don’t add up,” Cortizo acknowledges. Traditionally, the blame for this trend is laid on the big marketplaces such as Amazon, but this is a half-truth. “It is true that they generate this competitive dynamic, because in the end they build it into their platform, but it is also what consumers are asking for.”
The pain of paying
The pain of paying is a behavioural economics theory which holds that certain psychological barriers can stop us from making a particular purchase. Using cash instead of credit cards is a good example. Convenience charges (such as the high price of a soft drink from a hotel minibar) are another. But nothing illustrates this consumer attitude better than delivery costs. That handful of euros added at the end of the process makes many people give up before pressing the “buy” button. That is why some have chosen to separate this cost from the moment of payment and disguise it as something else. “Amazon Prime is dressed up as a package of series and films,” explains Jordi Ordóñez, a consultant specialising in ecommerce. “It is an effective way of attracting customers: you remove the barrier of delivery costs at the moment of purchase and you offer something extra. And it works: an Amazon Prime customer buys two or three times more than one who doesn’t have it.” Ordóñez believes the price of this service will rise over the years and that this will calm things down, but for now they are still in the phase of attracting customers, building loyalty and growing. And the discounts continue: free delivery has now been joined by returns at no extra cost. This is not a marginal amount. Around 25% of products or services bought online are returned, a figure that rises to 30% in the case of clothing. When it arrived in Spain, Amazon relied on companies such as Seur or MRW. They gave it a welcome worthy of Mister Marshall, but soon realised the American was not worth so much celebration. “At first everything went very well, but then they started tightening the screws: you must lower your price, you must always arrive on time… it reached a point where it was unsustainable,” Ordóñez recalls. That point came on Black Friday 2016, when the transport companies collapsed. The volume kept growing, but the profit per parcel kept shrinking. And the reputation of these companies, with accumulated delays of more than a week, hit rock bottom. “Just imagine a single customer overloading your entire distribution network. The others complain, and rightly so. And bear in mind that those others pay better. In the end you see it isn’t worth it,” the expert concludes. Little by little, the big delivery companies stopped working with Amazon. The tech giant filled this gap by setting up its own logistics network based on self-employed workers and subcontractors. Making delivery more precarious. For the least rewarding parcels, those bound for distant villages and remote houses, the numbers still did not add up. So it chose to look for an ally in need.
Obligation
Correos is required by law to provide the universal postal service and guarantee the delivery of letters and parcels throughout Spain at a competitive price. “This gives it enormous reach,” notes José Carlos Cortizo. And an equally enormous cost. “Since fewer letters are sent, which is what gave the service its purpose, it is running at an ever greater loss.” Spain pays Correos around 142 million a year in compensation for the losses of the universal postal service. In this situation, a company like Amazon comes along and offers a payment, albeit a meagre one, to use a network that has to be maintained and paid for by law, whether it is used or not. The answer is clear. “You have no choice but to accept,” Cortizo concludes. “Amazon is taking advantage of Correos’ need.” Jordi Ordóñez justifies this behaviour with an argument that is hard to refute: “At the end of the day they are companies, not NGOs, and they have to make money. If they can’t charge these costs to the customer, they have to put them somewhere.” That extra cost is spread along the chain, but it is usually the weakest link, logistics, that bears most of it. It already happened with deliveries and takeaway food. Now that model is being copied in online shopping. “It is the least valued part,” Ordóñez acknowledges. “Rather ironically, because if you think about it, it is the only point of contact between the shop and the customer. It is the visible face.” Ana Magallón, now past the hardest months of the crisis, is busy in the workshop again. “We are catching up on all the orders we had put on hold during these months of the pandemic,” she says with relief. There is background noise; her workshop in Avilés is already bustling. Women modelling, painting, wrapping and sending ceramic figurines. Magallón sounds surprised when asked why they don’t turn the workshop into a shop and leave the online world behind. “Because then we wouldn’t sell anything, and we’d have far more costs,” she replies. Selling online has its drawbacks, but for now the advantages win hands down. “We send orders to Puerto Rico, Qatar, the Philippines, South Africa…” Magallón lists. There is no argument. Barruntando will keep packing little ceramic mermaids and sending them to every corner of the world. Whoever ends up paying for the delivery.

